Skip to content
Vaccine passports: why proof of vaccination is so politically complicated

“The government does not currently support, and we will not, a system that requires Americans to own a title. There will be no federal database on vaccinations and no federal mandate requiring everyone to get one. proof of vaccination, “White House press secretary Jen Psaki told reporters.

The next question for many Americans is how to make sure that the person nearby – on a plane, in a restaurant, at school – has been vaccinated against Covid.

  1. Create a non-governmental system whereby people can prove their vaccinations to participate in certain aspects of life; an international plane trip or a cruise.
  2. It’s not your business.

The governors of Texas and Florida have both signed executive orders banning so-called “vaccine passports” or any other requirements imposed by local governments or businesses.

Last week, Florida Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis banned local governments from issuing any type of vaccine passport and banned businesses from requiring such a form to provide services.

He cited personal freedom and said such passports “would create two categories of citizens on the basis of vaccinations.”

Texas Republican Gov. Greg Abbott followed suit with his own ordinance, which bars Texas agencies from requiring a vaccine for any service.

“The government should not require any Texan to present proof of vaccination and reveal private health information just to go about its daily business,” he said in a video posted on Twitter.

The administration Biden has worked with nonprofits and tech companies to develop a set of standards for people to prove they have received the vaccine, according to at least two administration officials.

Airlines and cruise ships have all considered some form of vaccine verification.

This would be especially important for the cruise industry, which has close ties to Florida. Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings, for example, submitted a plan to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on Monday to return to operations from U.S. ports in July.

The plan includes a requirement that crew and guests be vaccinated: “We believe that through a combination of 100% mandatory guest and crew vaccinations and science-backed public health measures … we can create a safe, bubble-like environment. for guests and crew. We look forward to joining the rest of the travel, tourism and hospitality industries to participate in this next phase of our recovery. “

A requirement for vaccines for domestic travel seems unlikely, but very possible for international travel, especially if countries that currently require quarantines for travelers switch to vaccines.

International airlines expect a vaccine passport to help reopen travel.

“In the short term, yes, I think the vaccine passport will be useful in giving confidence to governments and passengers in our industry to start traveling again,” Qatar Airways Group CEO Akbar Al Baker told Tuesday. Hadley Gamble of CNBC.
Companies have already worked on apps that allow users to download information about their Covid vaccines or tests, then scan QR codes to access flights or concert halls.
The UK is similarly testing Covid vaccine certifications for residents who wish to attend football matches and other large gatherings, but will not require them to enter essential stores or public transport. Israel already has a “green pass” that allows holders to go to concerts or the theater.

Ask or demand

There is a big difference between asking for something and demanding it. And there is a difference between a business that needs something in return for its service and a government entity that requires it.

Texas and Florida businesses and stores still need masks, for example.

But there is also an anti-authority trend in this country, which is why the United States does not have a federal gun registry. There is no question of arguing that the government should not be given certain information.

In a pandemic with an economy trying to emerge, however, the interest of public safety must also be considered, especially when it comes to masks and vaccines specifically.

Check out mask-less photos from the sold-out Texas Rangers home opener. Or check out the pictures of spring breakers on Florida beaches. Florida has seen more cases of the dangerous B.1.17 Covid variant than any other state, according to the CDC. Vaccines seem to protect against it.

States need more vaccines

Children who attend school must receive many vaccines, depending on the state, in order to receive in-person public education. But reluctance to vaccinate, even for inoculations long used against polio and other diseases, has been a problem in classrooms in the United States.

It is not clear when children under the age of 16 will be eligible to receive Covid vaccines, let alone when school districts or states will need them. Additionally, the Covid vaccine is only licensed for emergency use, not fully licensed. This is why members of the armed forces have the option of obtaining it, rather than the battery of vaccines that they are required to have.

Confidentiality is a real issue. There are very real concerns, particularly if a list is to be maintained by a government entity. The United States Civil Liberties Union has warned of the privacy dangers of any type of vaccination passport and has compiled a list of its guidelines for a vaccination passport system:
  • It must be decentralized and open-source.
  • it should have a non-digital paper option.
  • it should not allow companies or governments to track a person’s movements.
The European vaccination passport. The European Commission unveiled its proposal for the European Union’s “digital green certificate” in March. No exact end date has been given for the certificates, with the commission saying they will be suspended once the World Health Organization declares the end of the international public health emergency caused by Covid-19.

But EU data protection bodies issued their own warnings on Tuesday, advising against expanding the use of vaccine passports beyond the current pandemic and warning that they could pose “risks to human rights. European citizens “.

Agencies have also expressed concerns about the prospect of a “de facto obligation” for people to present vaccine passports to enter shops, restaurants, clubs, places of worship and gymnasiums, as “has already been suggested. “.

Scrambling Reagan’s Advice

“Trust, but verify,” is the old contradictory Russian proverb President Ronald Reagan applied to Russians he did not trust to keep their promises of nuclear disarmament.

It is clouded by current vaccine policy, where there is a growing effort to ban a vetting process, and voting rights, where pressure for stricter voter identification rules is being pushed.

Vaccinate, do not check. Republican governors, after resisting science to ban mask requirements in their states, are trying to take the next step in Covid protection and ban anything that looks like a vaccine passport.

Check, then vote. The same governors, it should be noted, are pushing to put barriers between voters and polling stations to avoid the potential for voter fraud, there is no evidence.

Vaccinations are in progress, passport or not

Along with the Manhattan Project and the shooting of the moon, you can place the Covid vaccination effort.

More than a third of Americans have received a dose of something that was not there a year ago. President Joe Biden dismissed criticism that his vaccination goals were too easily attainable during a stop at a vaccination clinic in Alexandria, Va. On Tuesday and then picked up the pace, saying all Americans who want vaccine should be eligible to get one by April 19. and that 200 million hits should be in America’s arms by then.

There are real questions about whether the vaccines were distributed fairly, whether the government has done enough to integrate those hardest hit by the coronavirus, and how to engage the large portion of Americans who do not want the vaccine is on board.

But give the vaccination effort this: It was started under then-President Donald Trump and taken over by Biden, it includes the public sector working in concert with the private sector, it spans from local pharmacies to sites. massive vaccination programs. And it has brought America closer every day to a return to normalcy.

Read this from CNN’s Deidre McPhillips:

The United States is currently administering doses of the Covid-19 vaccine at a rate nearly five times the global average, and has fully immunized a larger portion of its population than most countries that have vaccinated for a period of time. similar, a CNN analysis suggests.

Over the past week, the United States has administered an average of more than three million doses per day, according to data released by the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. That’s over 900 shots per 100,000 people every day.

Globally, an average of 16 million shots were administered daily over the past week, according to data released by Our World in Data. It’s about 200 shots for 100,000 people every day.

Outperform Other Key Countries:

  • United States – More than 18% of the population has been fully vaccinated since mid-December.
  • UK – Around 8% of the population is fully vaccinated, although vaccines started earlier.
  • Canada – About 2% of the population is fully vaccinated, although it started when the United States did.
Note: UK has delayed second doses to get first doses to more people. Find more country specific data on CNN’s Global Vaccine Tracking here.


Source link