Skip to content
Judge rejects challenge to Oregon Second Amendment shrine effort

On Thursday, an Oregon judge clashed with local officials and a gun control group as he dismissed a challenge to a Second Amendment sanctuary ordinance that had previously been approved by voters.

The Columbia County Council of Commissioners requested a judicial review of the Second Amendment Sanctuary Ordinance on May 25, which bars law enforcement in the locality from enforcing most federal law enforcement provisions. fire arms. Officials at the time did not seek to “invalidate” the proposal. Instead, they sought to “get answers to the many legal questions raised by this one.”

Everytown for Gun Safety, a gun control advocacy group, and Oregon Attorney General Ellen Rosenblum then filed their own court documents opposing the sanctuary order. Despite their opposition, Judge Ted Grove ruled that no “justiciable controversy” was present to justify a legal decision on the matter.


“While a governing body can request a review of an order, even one that incorporates measures of initiative, judicial review always requires justiciable controversy,” Grove wrote. “The petitioners have not demonstrated such controversy.”

“The petitioners are not seeking to defend their order against a challenge or to resolve a conflict between the parties,” he added. “They are not trying to overcome resistance from the sheriff or the state police, and, as their submissions show, they would not defend their order at all even if challenged.”

Sarah Hansen, a Columbia County attorney, said Grove was wrong in her determination. She also indicated that the authorities do not know if they will appeal on this matter.

“I strongly disagree with Justice Grove’s ruling that there is no justiciable controversy in this case and his dismissal of the validation request,” she told the Columbia County Spotlight .


The Gun Owners of America, a prominent pro-Second Amendment organization that said it fought Everytown for Gun Safety alongside other like-minded groups in the legal battle, welcomed the judge’s ruling.

“Columbia County Commissioners and Everytown for Gun Safety attempted to undermine the credibility of the Second Amendment Sanctuary Orders, but showed no real controversy in court,” GOA Senior Vice President said, Erich Pratt, in a statement. “As over 60% of municipalities in the United States have adopted SASOs, this case marks a huge victory not only for gun owners in Columbia County, Oregon, but also for Second Amendment supporters. in all the countries. “

Washington Examiner Videos

Keywords: News, Second Amendment, Firearms, Oregon, Tribunal, Gun Control

Original author: Jake dima

Original location: Judge rejects challenge to Oregon Second Amendment shrine effort

Source link